A wealthy Canadian businessman transferred more than $30 million to the woman hired to care for his ill wife, and after his death the question of whether those transfers were gifts has become the centre of a major estate dispute. On November 12, the Ontario Court of Appeal ordered a new trial in Waters Estate v. Henry, finding that the original judge made errors in how he treated the evidence and the legal burden, according to Blaneys Appeals and Law360 Canada.The case involves a man who hired a personal support worker for his housebound wife in 2009. Within weeks, he began transferring large sums to her, and over the next decade he moved more than $30 million across at least 393 transfers. The Court of Appeal has now sent the matter back for a fresh trial to determine whether the money was intended as a gift or was held in trust for the estate.
What the transfers involved
Between 2009 and December 2019, the businessman transferred more than $30 million to the caregiver in at least 393 transactions. About $19 million went toward buying and renovating properties, while much of the rest funded cars, trips, jewellery, and other personal spending.Some of the money belonged to the businessman’s wife, which he controlled under a power of attorney. The estate argued that most of the transfers were investments subject to a resulting trust, while the caregiver claimed they were gifts within a secret intimate relationship.The trial judge had found that the caregiver rebutted the presumption of resulting trust for almost all of the transfers. That finding is now under review after the Court of Appeal identified problems with how the evidence and legal burden were handled.
Why the Court of Appeal intervened
The Court of Appeal held that the trial judge effectively reversed the onus by looking for evidence that the deceased intended to keep an interest in the transfers. Under the law of resulting trusts, the burden is on the person claiming the money was a gift to show that the deceased intended to give it away.The court also found that the trial judge wrongly excluded the deceased’s handwritten notes as hearsay. The court said those notes could show an implied assertion that the deceased was tracking his investments, which could be relevant to whether the transfers were gifts.In addition, the court held that the intimate relationship between the deceased and the caregiver was context, not the independent corroboration required under section 13 of the Evidence Act. This distinction matters because the caregiver’s claim that the transfers were gifts rests partly on the nature of their relationship.
What the new trial will decide
The new trial will focus on whether the more than $30 million in transfers were gifts or were held on resulting trust for the estate. The court will need to examine the evidence again with the correct legal framework in place.The Court of Appeal did uphold one part of the original decision. It found that the deceased kept an 80 percent interest in a horse farm business known as King of Hearts, and it upheld the order that the caregiver repay $1,938,000 of the wife’s money.That means the new trial will not revisit every issue from the original case. It will focus on the transfers and whether they were gifts, while the horse farm finding and the repayment order remain in place.
What the case shows
The case is an example of how messy these disputes can become when large sums of money are involved and the person who made the transfers is no longer alive to explain his intentions. The estate argues that the money was invested, while the caregiver argues it was given freely.The legal framework matters because a resulting trust presumes that the person who transferred the money retained an interest unless the recipient can prove otherwise. That presumption is what the Court of Appeal says the trial judge failed to apply correctly.The case also shows how evidence such as handwritten notes can become important. The court found that the deceased’s notes could shed light on whether he was tracking investments, which could support the estate’s position that the transfers were not gifts.
What happens next?
The new trial will allow both sides to present their case and evidence again. The estate will need to show that the transfers were not gifts, while the caregiver will need to prove that they were.The Court of Appeal’s decision does not settle the question of who owns the money. It simply means that the original trial judge’s findings on that issue cannot stand, and the matter must be decided again.For the family, the case is about recovering money they believe belongs to the estate. For the caregiver, it is about defending transfers she says were gifts. The new trial will determine which version of events the court accepts.